In case anyone missed this, we’re in a bit of a tight labor market. Too many workers, not enough work. Unfortunately, that means there is also an equally disturbing increase in job listings aimed at freelance writers that are abominable at best.
But there’s an uptick in yet another disturbing facet of the “get writing help for nothing” crowd. Volunteer positions.
Mind you, there are plenty of legitimate volunteer organizations out there. If you have spare time and the desire to help out, that’s great. But what I’m seeing is volunteer positions for nonprofits I’ve never heard of, or organizations sounding like nonprofits, but may not be true nonprofits. Or the more blatant offense — companies that are simply out for free work, feeding off your desperation.
Thanks to Gabriella for pointing out one particularly disturbing gig. The organization lists itself as a nonprofit news organization. The information I dug up on this nonprofit says that they publish things that tend to leave out facts if those facts would hurt their bias. That in itself disqualifies them in my book. But their latest job posting puts that final nail in the coffin. Here are some excerpts:
…. we’re looking for volunteers — skilled volunteers. Yes, we’re a nonprofit that wasn’t funded by a zillionaire… Yes, we have a tiny budget right now and simply don’t have the ability to pay many people very much.
But we promise you this: If you do an excellent job, over time we’ll find a way to compensate you as we’re able….
Not that old chestnut again. This ad has everything we’ve come to find in a low-paying gig, which those low-paying gigs are looking pretty attractive right now, aren’t they?
But if you’re just itching to work for them, here are the duties:
Responsibilities
-
Manage the editorial team to ensure news production happens on time, accurately, and to the best of our editorial ability
-
Analyze our current editorial processes, identify weaknesses, and build systems to help the newsroom run more smoothly
-
Define complicated tasks, set deadlines, and delegate work while keeping our “big picture” in mind
-
Collaborate with the Marketing/Branding, Creative, and Operations departments on consistent messaging throughout the organization
So you’re basically running the newsroom. You’re shoring up their operations, working with every team to strengthen the organization, and you’re getting zero pay from it. Zero. They’ve told you that up front.
Let’s not forget the requirements:
-
Bachelor’s Degree or higher
-
Proven experience in management and operation of complex editorial structures and processes
-
The ability to define and delegate tasks, and motivate others
-
Strong organizational and communication skills
-
The ability to self-direct and manage others working remotely
-
The patience to monitor multiple individuals, projects, and processes
There you go. You have to be a pro with a degree. You have to have experience. You have to be a manager.
And for your skill level, you get this:
Perks
-
Channel your passion in a stimulating environment
-
Learn the nuts and bolts of nonprofit operations in an up-and-coming organization
-
Develop new skills and gain valuable experience that can enhance your professional trajectory
-
Do amazing work on a flexible, part-time basis
-
Have fun while you make a difference
Wow. So you, pro manager, can channel that passion into a stimulating, non-paying job.
“Up-and-coming organization” — isn’t that usually a euphemism for low pay? Well, now it’s one for no pay, too.
Oh, and you get to “enhance” your “professional trajectory” which apparently means you can learn a hard lesson in why it’s a bad idea to take a volunteer job that sucks up all your time for no pay.
Have fun while you make a difference — what difference? Who is benefitting from this nonprofit other than the people getting paid?
Then there are the expectations. Oh yes, there are expectations (let’s just call them requirements):
You will work remotely and on your own schedule. We also ask for a minimum commitment of 10-15 hours a week (Though doing more is not discouraged!).
Yea, I bet it’s not.
Here’s why this job bugs me:
This isn’t much of a nonprofit. It’s a news organization. I’m not exactly sure what grants it nonprofit status, but damn if this doesn’t look, sound, and feel like a publishing group. If a publisher can set themselves up as a nonprofit, what’s to stop other companies from doing the same? There’s no pay, but you’re expected to be the main cog in the wheel that keeps this place running. You have to bust your hump for no compensation so that someone somewhere benefits, though we’re not really sure who that is at the moment.
If you’re thinking of volunteering, please vet your volunteer organization to make sure they’re serving a population you’re interested in helping. If you’re looking for work or any kind of stepping stone, please be paid for it. Here’s one option:
Remote Content Producer (Written) at HelpDocs
As a Content Producer (Written) on the Customer Education team you’ll be working closely with the company founders to write long-form blog posts, guides, website copy, and other educational content for our users.
- Write 1500+ word story-based blog posts about your experiences, customer support, startups, and remote life
- Identify and act on opportunities to do partner marketing (e.g. guest posts, etc.)
- Write research-driven guides and other long-form educational content to educate our users
- Update our website copy to optimize for SEO and readability
- Design and improve customer onboarding sequences
- Keep our help documentation up to date in response to customer queries and new features
- Create content for social media (including sourcing interesting articles to share)
Perks
- ~ 28 paid vacation days per year. Take the time you need to be healthy and happy. We’re not counting—this is honor based.
- One fully-paid team retreat. We’ll go somewhere nice for a week and HelpDocs’ll pick up all your expenses.
- $300/m healthcare stipend toward private health insurance
- 12 weeks fully paid parental leave
- $70/m towards a gym membership or other fitness activities
- $2k equipment allowance given every 3 years.
Pay
The range for this role is $54-65k per year. We don’t pay on location. We have bands based on experience. You’ll be retained as a full-time consultant and responsible for your own taxes.
What kind of volunteering would appeal to you? Do you volunteer now for any organization?
9 responses to “The Rise of the Volunteer Freelance Gigs”
When I saw this post, I knew I had to send it to Lori!
Look, I’m involved in a nonprofit dog rescue. And, yep, I’ve written real articles for which I’ve interviewed people. And I’m the lead on the biannual newsletter, where I write a bunch of stuff.
Yep, all nonpaid. But that’s because it makes my heart sing, helping dogs.
It doesn’t make my heart sing to earn nothing while making others profitable.
I don’t get it.
The worst example? All those fools who wrote for HuffPo for free and then let Arianna sell it for something like $300 million. I STILL won’t read HuffPo for that reason–I won’t give a single click that made its money off of unpaid work that should have been paid.
OK, I’ll stop. But this one is a head scratcher for me. Thanks, Lori, for making this point so well!
Thank you, Gabriella! This is a trend I’m not happy about in the least. HuffPo has had me steaming for a decade over their nonpayment policy. Why the hell should I work to make them rich at the cost of my own earnings?
I hear you on the charity work. It has to be something that makes you feel good, not something that makes someone else overwork you for their own financial gain. No. Thanks!
I’m still recuperating from all the jobs I had in the 90s slaving for companies that sold out to mergers. Now, too many nonprofits are shells for what amount to mobs. They’ve refined the art of using enablers like me who learned the hard way. They just keep looking for fresh blood. I’m not bitter.
All of what you said, Gina. Every bit! Nonprofits being shells — so true. And they do feed on people’s emotions. They give promises, they tell you you’ll be doing good deeds, all of the triggers that make us trust and get on board.
I had that happen once. The guy had quite literally faked a charity and he was good — he managed to get me to volunteer to write a press release for free. That ended when the cops in his area alerted me to who he was. From that point, I decided it’s payment upfront, and I’m checking out everyone before I get on board.
It’s hard not to be bitter, isn’t it?
I was too shell shocked to be properly bitter. Those jobs I had were mostly administrative – but even now, how do we all process how our whole system has been run more and more the way you describe. Writers, of all people, should lead the way out. You are an example, Lori!
We writers need to get backbones and some self-respect and do more than say no. We need to educate our peers, like you say — lead the way out.
Thanks, Lori. You’re right. We need an army of writers. It would be sooo much easier. : )
Well, that volunteer gig was a stinker, wasn’t it, Lori? They want a heck of a lot for no pay.
Didn’t they, Sharon? It’s shocking that they’re calling that a volunteer job. With required hours. If it’s volunteer and I show up for just eight hours a week, how are you going to “fire” me? What motivates me to stick around?
They didn’t think this through very well. 😉